This Is the No. 1 Tourist Destination Letdown in the U.S.—but Here’s How to Visit It Properly

The day after I graduated from college, my sister and I flew to New York City, meticulously plotting out our visit hour-by-hour in a spiral notebook. But the moment we got to the city, we ditched the plan and beelined for Times Square. Hours later, she was live on MTV’s TRL (yes, this was 1999!) announcing the No. 1 song—and we instantly believed this was the place where dreams come true. 

A few years later, my office was smack dab in the middle of Times Square. While my co-workers complained about the constant hoards of tourists, I secretly loved stepping right into the excitement.

Now that I’ve lived here 22 years, I know and understand the reputation of that the district around the intersection where Broadway and Seventh Avenue has. For global travelers, Times Square a must-see, standing among the skyscrapers and screens among the street performers and costumed characters luring travelers. For locals, it’s the one place to totally avoid.

So when I learned analysts at CasiMonka named Times Square the “biggest tourist destination letdown” in the world—with reviews calling it “expensive” and “touristy”—I instantly got defensive.

As perhaps the most famous New Year’s Eve destination in the world for its ball drop, a tradition since 1907, of course anyone who visits the city year-round craves a piece of that thrill, inherently turning it into a “touristy” place. Plus compared to where many travelers are coming from, the cost of living is higher. But like anywhere else, there are budget-friendly options that still give you the ultimate Big Apple experience, if you know where to look. 

In fact, one of my most frequented spots is the Hershey’s Store because I’m always handed free chocolate as soon as I enter. (I was so obsessed with this that when I worked near Rockefeller Center for four years at a company that provided car service home, I’d turn it down just to unwind and walk through Times Square savoring that sweet treat in hand.)

While dining anywhere in New York City can cost a pretty penny, some of my favorite affordable options are also in Times Square, and their diversity showcases the global influence of the city’s cuisine.

At the top of the list for a full-service meal is an outpost of Japanese ramen shop Ichiran with individual wooden booths for each diner. Its classic Tonkotsu ramen is $22 flat, as a no-tipping establishment. The Italian sandwich shop All’Antico Vinaio serves up Florence-style quick bites, and whenever I have family in town, we always go to Tony’s DiNapoli for family-style Italian homecooking.

There’s also been a recent surge of authentic Asian eats, giving the city’s Chinatown and Koreatown serious competition. An outpost of one of the world’s most inexpensive Michelin-starred restaurants Tim Ho Wan serves dim sum, while the Taiwanese soup dumpling favorite Din Tai Fung opened its largest restaurant yet in Times Square last year. So many of my favorites in the city are within the district, like Four Four South Village for Taiwanese beef noodles, Kung Fu Little Steamed Buns and Kung Fu Kitchen for no-frills dumplings and noodles, The Handpulled Noodle for customizable noodle entrees, and Dim Sum Sam for wonton noodle soup.

There is also the famous Restaurant Row on 46th Street with longtime mainstay Becco for Italian, while Don’t Tell Mama is always fun for a dose of entertainment with your meal and Joe Allen is popular for the the theater community for its wall of Broadway flops, as Kristin Chenoweth told T+L. 

Of course, Times Square overlaps with the Theater District, with 41 Broadway theaters featuring the world’s best musicals and plays, many with star-studded casts. Right now you can catch George Clooney in Good Night, and Good Luck and both Denzel Washington and Jake Gyllenhaal in Othello. There’s never been a better time to take in a show, as this current season is Broadway’s highest-grossing in history.

While tickets prices can be high, over two decades, I’ve seen hundreds of shows for less than $100—often less than $50. Keep in mind that most theaters offer lotteries or rush tickets, and platforms like TodayTix, Theatr, and Broadway Inbound also offer deals. For same-day seats, there’s also the famous TKTS booth. With so many shows to choose from, it can be hard to navigate, but Wicked, Gypsy, Hamilton, and The Great Gatsby are great for first-timers, as well as personal favorites Maybe Happy Ending and Just In Time.

Theater lovers should also make time to visit the Museum of Broadway, also in the neighborhood, and can even put on your dancing shoes for one of 50 daily drop-in classes at Broadway Dance Center—I’ve never felt more like a Broadway star that when I tap danced in the neighborhood. Other empowering city moments: practicing yoga with hundreds of strangers for the annual Solstice in Times Square and running through its streets during the New York City Half Marathon.

Like any other city hub, the hotel options can be pricey and room merely functional. But there there’s also been a resurgence of boutique-style hotels, like the Civilian Hotel with a cozy artsy atmosphere and Kimpton Theta whose rooftop Bar Sprezzatura is like an Italian seaside getaway, and elevated The Times Square EDITION with The Terrace and Outdoor Gardens with a refreshed menu that includes frozen s’mores. “The Terrace and Outdoor Gardens feels like a sanctuary in the neighborhood,” Susmita Baral, a senior editor at T+L said. “Aside from having quality food and a charming aesthetic, it truly transports you to a zen space.”

While the constant hubbub can be overwhelming, I’ve found calm within the area’s coffee shops, often spend my days writing at Bird and Branch, which offers a fun coffee flight, Frisson Espresso, where I’m bound to overhear conversations from Broadway folks, and Bibble and Sip with cutesy desserts that are equally tasty.

Despite being pulled in so many directions in Times Square, every night there’s a unifying moment at 11:57pm, when all 92 digital screens from 41st to 49th Streets sync up with the work of contemporary artists for three minutes in Time Square Alliance’s Midnight Moment—definitely worth experiencing.

While my status of being a “real” New Yorker is threatened by admitting that my favorite neighborhood to work and play is Times Square, I will always remind travelers and locals alike to pause and look up and remember the words of Frank Sinatra, “If you can make it here, you can make it anywhere.” And there’s no better place to find yourself than in the heart of New York City than Times Square.